Favorite

Single-payer is cheaper 

The enemies of Obamacare and Arkansas's peculiar version of it, the "private option," exposed what they hoped would be a dirty little secret the other day: The government spends more on the private option than it would have spent on plain-vanilla Medicaid, the undiluted Obamacare that other participating states follow.

That was not exactly what the Government Accountability Office set out to prove in a little report for Sen. Orrin Hatch (R-Utah) and Rep. Fred Upton (R-Mich.), inveterate foes of Obamacare (although Hatch and 18 other GOP senators signed on as sponsors of its blueprint in 1993), but it served their purpose. That was to create the impression that the much-ballyhooed Arkansas plan is more expensive for the government and the taxpayers than it needs to be.

Maybe it could even be the nudge that kills the private option next year when a new governor and a legislature with perhaps a diminished majority for the private option take a new look at it. Maybe it will help conservatives realize the goal of ending health coverage for some 225,000 poor Arkansans who until a year ago could not afford either insurance or medical care when they got sick.

Hatch's and Upton's big objective was to discourage other red states from following Arkansas and jumping into the Medicaid expansion. Look, they can say, the Arkansas plan is flawed and will have to be scrapped, so you don't want to follow the lead of those treasonous Arkansas Republicans.

The Republican authors of the private option aren't deterred by the GAO report, nor are Gov. Beebe, the officials who run the Medicaid program or all the providers around Arkansas who think Obamacare, including the private option, is the best single development for public health in the state's history, except for the enactment of Medicare and Medicaid in 1965.

But here is the truth they don't want to admit: That dirty little secret is right. The private option costs the government and the taxpayers more than merely enrolling those 225,000 poor grownups in Medicaid. That was obvious from the first, although the authors of the option produced a formula for justifying it that suggests that it would cost no more than straight Medicaid and maybe much less. They harbor undying faith that the market (insurance carriers) will always do things cheaper and better than the government — pay much more for all the medical procedures than do Medicaid and Medicare while keeping enough money for executive salaries, administrative overhead and promotion. The overwhelming evidence, at least in health care, is that it does not.

The rationale they offered for the private option is that if Medicaid got doctors and hospitals to take all those poor patients it would have to substantially increase its low reimbursement rates, and if people instead used the government's money to buy private policies the government would reap heavy premium taxes from the companies. Also, Arkansas's private option carves off the sickest and costliest people — the medically frail — and assigns them to Medicaid, a huge saving for the companies.

Medicaid hasn't jacked up its reimbursement rates and who knows whether it would have if the state had implemented direct Medicaid? But the undeniable truth is that the expansion without the private option would not have been as successful so quickly in reaching so many Arkansans. Many people feel better about owning an insurance policy than accepting what they think of as welfare, and insurers, hospitals and doctors aided in signing people up for the better-paying insurance. Significantly, the heavy use of the private option drove down premiums for people in the private exchange.

If saving a bundle of taxpayer dollars is all that matters to Hatch, Upton and those who seize on the GAO report to say the private option must go, they logically ought to concede a larger point. A single-payer system of insurance like Medicaid and Medicare is the cheaper, more efficient way to go to guarantee access to health care for all Americans, which Republicans have always rejected, which is why we got the market-based systems of Romneycare and Obamacare.

Have you read all the recent conservative idolatry of Canada? It is the new free-market, low-tax, low-spending paradise whose policies our government should be emulating. It has a bigger safety net than the United States but a budget that is in better control and business-friendlier tax policies.

But there are good explanations for that beyond tax policy and a cheap currency. One is that Canada has a government-run single-payer health system similar to Medicaid that insures everyone, including visitors. There is a high quotient of happiness with it. Canada spends only 10.9 percent of its roaring GDP on health care, compared with our world-leading 18 percent.

"If you want to do spending austerity, single payer is a powerful tool," David Frum, President George W. Bush's speech writer and conservative commentator, said the other day. If that's where Orrin Hatch and other critics of the private option and Obamacare want us to go, they'll get no quarrel from this quarter.

Favorite

Sign up for the Daily Update email

Speaking of...

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

More by Ernest Dumas

  • Week That Was

    After the wildest week of the wildest presidency in history, the clouded future suddenly unfolds more clearly and, yes, nearer. That includes the end of the Trump presidency.
    • Apr 19, 2018
  • The pathetic fallacy

    What do you call an idea that grows in popularity the more it is proven wrong? Let's steal John Ruskin's literary term, "the pathetic fallacy," because it is more descriptive than his use of it.
    • Apr 12, 2018
  • Teachers and tax cuts

    In a year of odd phenomena, none is odder than this: Across the nation's midsection, schoolteachers are suddenly fed up with their government's treatment of education and educators, and Republican governors and legislatures are capitulating right and left, even raising taxes to mollify them.
    • Apr 5, 2018
  • More »

Readers also liked…

  • Along the civil rights trail

    A convergence of events in recent days signaled again how far we have come and how far we have yet to go in civil rights.
    • Jan 18, 2018
  • The Oval outhouse

    One thing all Americans finally can agree upon is that public discourse has coarsened irretrievably in the era of Donald Trump and largely at his instance.
    • Jan 18, 2018
  • Shrugging off sulfides

    The Arkansas Democrat-Gazette reported a shocker on its front page Sunday. The rotten-egg odor from the Koch brothers' sprawling paper plant at Crossett is still making people sick, but the state's pollution control agency is unaware of the problem.
    • Mar 29, 2018

Latest in Ernest Dumas

  • Week That Was

    After the wildest week of the wildest presidency in history, the clouded future suddenly unfolds more clearly and, yes, nearer. That includes the end of the Trump presidency.
    • Apr 19, 2018
  • The pathetic fallacy

    What do you call an idea that grows in popularity the more it is proven wrong? Let's steal John Ruskin's literary term, "the pathetic fallacy," because it is more descriptive than his use of it.
    • Apr 12, 2018
  • Teachers and tax cuts

    In a year of odd phenomena, none is odder than this: Across the nation's midsection, schoolteachers are suddenly fed up with their government's treatment of education and educators, and Republican governors and legislatures are capitulating right and left, even raising taxes to mollify them.
    • Apr 5, 2018
  • More »

Most Viewed

  • Redefining candidate quality

    Despite what national party organizations like the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee and the National Republican Campaign Committee say, conventional definitions of candidate quality are not leading to progressive wins in 2018.
  • Stormy shaming

    Can we talk about Stormy Daniels? More specifically, can we talk about how we talk about Stormy Daniels?
  • Trump and Comey

    In the Bizarro World of the Trump administration, it's only fitting that the president serves as publicity director for James Comey's big book tour. (In the old Superman comics, Bizarro World was an upside-down reality where wickedness was virtue and vice versa.) Supposedly, Trump's stomping around the White House and various golf courses red-faced with anger, emitting smoke from his ears.

Most Recent Comments

  • Re: Stormy shaming

    • I do not automatically have contempt for women who have careers built around selling sex…

    • on April 19, 2018
  • Re: Stormy shaming

    • And if new 15 minutes of fame celebrity is a fat, fast-food worker then she'd…

    • on April 18, 2018
  • Re: Stormy shaming

    • Very well said. Great piece of writing for a lawyer. Wink.

    • on April 18, 2018
 

© 2018 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation