Tax truths 

The idea that a tax cut for the wealthy will help everyone, though false, is a stubbornly marketable notion.

The idea that a tax cut for the wealthy will help everyone, though false, is a stubbornly marketable notion. Perhaps Peter Lindert, distinguished professor of economics at the University of California-Davis, says it best: "It is well known that higher taxes and transfers reduce productivity. Well known — but unsupported by statistics and history." Unfortunately, this falsehood persists in being "well known" both at the federal level and at home in Arkansas's legislature.

Let's take the most recent in a long line of research on this topic. The Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy compared nine states without income taxes to nine states with the highest income tax rates. Like other studies, they found that there was little evidence that zero-income-tax states were booming. In fact, in many categories, "high-tax" states blew their counterparts out of the water. The states with high income taxes had better economic growth, faster income growth and better employment opportunities. In zero-income-tax states, job growth did worse at keeping up with population growth.

This is not to say that higher income taxes caused these benefits; the point is that the income tax rate alone is largely irrelevant to economic success. And if the states with no income tax at all aren't getting anything out of the deal, what can we hope to achieve from lowering our top rate a few percentage points? The only sure thing from zero-income-tax states is that the wealthiest people in those states get a lot of benefits, and that those benefits come off the backs of everyday workers.

This is a good time to remember that Arkansas already asks lower income people to pay a bigger share of their income to state and local taxes. We are even harder on low-income people than most other states. Arkansas is the 11th worst in the nation for overburdening the poor and letting the wealthy slide on their tax bill (who remembers the capital gains exemption for people making more than $10 million a year?).

In our state, a full-time childcare worker making around minimum wage ($18,000 a year) would pay twice the rate in state and local taxes as a businessman making around $350,000 a year. The childcare worker pays about 12 percent while the businessman pays just under 6 percent. In fact, low-wage workers aren't just paying a higher rate directly because of the current tax system. Their gap in pretax income is also partly a product of the tax system itself. Economists like Thomas Piketty have linked previous cuts in U.S. top tax rates to increasing income inequality, not economic growth. In other words, not only do low-wage workers face higher state and local tax rates, they also likely would have been earning higher wages in the first place if our tax system were more equal.

Sure, if you would rather look at the total tax bill instead of the rate, the businessman is paying more, but the efforts of their contributions look very different. Just look at the time it takes to pay off state and local tax bills. If you believe the most valuable thing we have is our time, you will want to know who is spending more hours investing tax dollars toward the public good in Arkansas. The childcare worker works until around Feb. 12 to pay off their state and local tax bill for the year. The businessman is done by Jan. 19, three full weeks earlier.

Cutting personal income tax rates would make the stark inequalities in Arkansas even worse, and will undercut our hopes of ever affording the investments that would promote our economic success. A progressive income tax structure that asks people to contribute according to their ability to pay does not hurt growth. Income taxes improve our state's ability to invest in what would really move us to the front: a world-class public education system, access to quality health care, highways and roads, and systems that help children who need our help the most, such as child welfare and juvenile justice.

Eleanor Wheeler is a senior policy analyst for Arkansas Advocates for Children and Families.


From the ArkTimes store


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

More by Ellie Wheeler

  • Left behind

    Arkansas is getting a lot of attention for our very low unemployment rate. If you look only at that number (3.4 percent), you would think workers here were doing quite well — better than surrounding states and even the nation as a whole. But that seemingly simple rate can hide some huge gaps in prosperity.
    • Sep 7, 2017
  • More »

Readers also liked…

  • Schlafly's influence

    Phyllis Schlafly, mother, attorney and longtime antifeminist, died recently. What Schlafly promoted was not novel or new. Men had been saying that men and women were not equal for years. However, anti-feminism, anti-women language had much more power coming from a woman who professed to be looking out for the good of all women and families.
    • Sep 15, 2016
  • Seven

    The controversy over the Ten Commandments monument on the Capitol lawn just won't go away.
    • Feb 9, 2017
  • Why a change of leadership at the LRSD now?

    Johnny Key's abrupt, unilateral decision to not renew Baker Kurrus' contract as superintendent strikes us as shortsighted, misguided and detrimental to the education of our children and the health of our community.
    • Apr 21, 2016

Latest in Guest Writer

  • Can't afford to gut ACA

    The Affordable Care Act was passed into law with the promise that it would make insurance affordable. Because of bipartisan leadership in Arkansas, we continue to strive to achieve that goal. While rhetoric abounds, it is important to understand the Arkansas experience.
    • Sep 21, 2017
  • Tipping point

    I was extremely cautious before engaging in the educational debate about the State Board of Education's decision to take over the Little Rock School District.
    • Sep 14, 2017
  • More »

Event Calendar

« »


  1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30  

© 2017 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation