Favorite

Worse than N.C.'s bathroom bill 

SB 774 extends birth certificate requirement to bathrooms in all public facilities, and that's an original birth certificate, too.

The basketball teams from the flagship state universities in North Carolina and Arkansas played an exciting game in the NCAA Tournament on Sunday. At the same time, the Arkansas General Assembly was pondering whether to enter a different sort of contest with North Carolina by passing a competing anti-transgender "bathroom bill." Senate Bill 774 is clearly inspired by the infamous House Bill 2 that has served as a disruptive force in the Tar Heel State's politics and economics since its passage a year ago. Last week, state Sen. Linda Collins-Smith (R-Pocahontas), the chief sponsor of the "Physical Privacy and Safety Act," presented her legislation to the Senate Judiciary Committee. Although Collins-Smith pulled it down from a vote because it lacked the votes for a committee green light, the bill's fate remains unclear as there is still time for it to begin moving in the legislative process following revisions to the legislation.

At the hearing, Collins-Smith claimed that her proposed legislation differs from the North Carolina law. She's right. It's more problematic in two important ways.

The bulk of SB 774 is clearly modeled on HB 2, down to the definitions developed for many of the key concepts such as "changing facility" and "government entity" and the exceptions to the overarching policy that only individuals of one sex may use single-sex bathrooms and changing facilities open to multiple persons. Like the North Carolina law, the policy covers bathrooms and locker rooms in any public building across the state.

There are two major differences between HB 2 and SB 774. Both make the legislation even more objectionable than HB 2. First, while HB 2 requires one to use a bathroom matching the sex on his or her current birth certificate, SB 774 requires one to use the facilities matching the sex on the individual's original birth certificate. Assuming the current legislature does not bar the practice (a bill to do that failed in a House committee last week), Arkansas has a fairly straightforward judicial process for changing one's sex on a birth certificate based on a doctor's notice that a sex change has occurred. No matter what one's current birth certificate states, SB 774 requires one to use the bathroom matching the sex on the birth certificate issued at birth, a sex deemed "immutable" by the law. In response to a question from Gretchen Hall, the head of the Little Rock Convention and Visitors Bureau, about how those covered by the legislation might actually effectively weed out those in the bathroom that didn't match their original birth documents, Collins-Smith responded: "It's your job to find a way."

SB 744 is also decidedly more problematic than HB 2 through its inclusion of a section allowing individuals whose privacy was "invaded" by sharing a bathroom with someone of a different sex (at least according to their original birth certificate) to file suit in either state or federal court against the governmental entity that had been slack in its policing of those who enter its bathrooms. The offended party would have up to four years to file suit for the harm done to them and could gain compensation from the state or local governmental entity for any "psychological, emotional, and physical harm." Such expansion of tort liability (and undermining of state sovereign immunity) is ironic considering that one of the state constitutional amendments being sent to Arkansas voters by the legislature sharply limits tort liability dramatically in medical malpractice cases.

In the lead on the opposition to SB 774 to date have been the elements of the business community most likely to feel the impact of a loss of tourism (i.e. the hospitality industry) and government-owned facilities like North Little Rock's Verizon Arena. Their engagement is driven by the impact of HB 2 on North Carolina's economy. In the past year, the state has felt what the Greensboro mayor called a "manmade recession." The hit on North Carolina's economy has been estimated at $630 million with the biggest losers being the low-wage workers relying directly on jobs related to concerts and sporting events that have been canceled because of boycotts of the state. A facility similar to Verizon, the Greensboro Coliseum, claims that the facility and its vendors have lost over $200,000 because of cancelations tied to HB 2.

Behind the scenes, as occurred with the religious freedom legislation in the 2015 session, the state's largest corporations are also pushing against a piece of legislation that could badly damage the state's image. And, if SB 774 begins to move through the legislative process, higher education institutions also no doubt will become more public in their opposition to legislation that is contrary to their values and interests (the national powerhouse Razorback track and field program would be prevented from hosting national championships, for instance).

Perhaps it goes without saying, but it is the "Physical Privacy and Safety" of transgender persons that is put at risk by this singularly discriminatory piece of legislation. Hopefully, the General Assembly will not seek to one-up North Carolina in targeting citizens that instead deserve protection and respect.

Favorite

Sign up for the Daily Update email

Speaking of Bathroom Bill

  • State tourism official warns of economic damage from "bathroom bill'

    November 3, 2017
    John Lovett of the Times-Record in Fort Smith reports on remarks this week by top state tourism officials and a warning about the damaging impact on tourism should Arkansas adopt a so-called bathroom bill that prevents transgender people from using restrooms that match their gender identity. /more/
  • The bathroom bill lives UPDATE

    June 21, 2017
    The Senate Judiciary Commitee voted Wednesday to have interim hearings on Sen. Linda Collins-Smith bathroom bill, an effort to prohibit transgender people from using facilities that match their identity. /more/
  • NCAA 'reluctantly' relents on North Carolina after HB2 repeal

    April 4, 2017
    The NCAA board of governors has decided to no longer boycott North Carolina for championship events because of the legislature's recent repeal of HB 2. It said a majority of its board o "reluctantly voted to allow consideration" of cities in the state. /more/
  • ACLU, HRC, Ark. Trans Equality Coalition decry anti-trans bills

    March 20, 2017
    In a press conference on the steps of the Arkansas State Capitol this morning, representatives of the Arkansas Transgender Equality Coalition (ARTEC), ACLU of Arkansas and a transgender pioneer spoke out against a number of anti-trans and anti-LGBT bills working their way through the state legislature. Citing the economic and political fallout for North Carolina over their "bathroom bill," the groups say the bills will harm the Arkansas economy. /more/
  • Filmmaker criticizes Arkansas bathroom bill

    March 19, 2017
    The House Friday adopted legislation by Rep. Bob Ballinger that advocates of transgender people say is a "Bathroom Lite" bill aimed at creating a means for a criminal penalty for people who use a restroom or locker room for a gender different than their gender at birth. /more/
  • Hospitality, restaurant groups oppose bathroom bill

    March 16, 2017
    Add the restaurant and hospitality association to those opposed to Sen. Linda Collins-Smith's bill to keep transgender people out of public restrooms that match their gender identity. /more/
  • Bathroom bill fight is far from over

    March 3, 2017
    Don't be misled by headlines that say Sen. Greg Standridge (R-Russellville) will withdraw a broad bill to prohibit use of any public restroom by someone with a birth certificate that doesn't match the posted gender. The bathroom fight isn't over. /more/
  • Bathroom bill retreat, but not total surrender

    March 2, 2017
    The Associated Press' Andrew DeMillo says Sen. Greg Standridge intends to drop a broad bathroom bill to prohibit public restroom use except by people with matching birth gender.But he says he still has something in mind on school facilities /more/
  • Hot Springs chamber opposes bathroom bill

    February 24, 2017
    Add a Hot Springs business group to the list opposing proposed legislation to require that public restrooms be used by people with matching birth gender (the final legislation isn't on file; who knows what it will require for those with indeterminate gender at birth.) It's cold comfort giving the multiple ways in which the legislature, governor, attorney general and others defend legal discrimination against LGBT people in Arkansas. /more/
  • More objections to the bathroom bill from Buffalo River businessman

    February 19, 2017
    A tourism operator in the district of a senator who's sponsored a "bathroom bill" to discourage transgender use of public facilities has joined those objecting to the legislation as damaging to business. /more/
  • More »

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Latest in Jay Barth

  • Ways to serve

    Last Friday, the statewide newspaper included two prominent headlines about former Arkansas state senators. On the front page was the story of former Sen. Jon Woods' conviction on 15 of 17 counts in a federal public corruption case in Fayetteville, a trial masterfully reported throughout by the veteran Arkansas journalist Doug Thompson. On the front of the Arkansas section was a celebratory obituary observing the death of former Sen. Jim Argue (D-Little Rock) from an aggressive kidney cancer. Two very different headlines about two very different men who happened to hold the same public office.
    • May 10, 2018
  • Medicaid favor

    Arkansas's distinctive form of Medicaid expansion has been precarious since its creation in 2013 by a bipartisan coalition.
    • Apr 26, 2018
  • On institutions

    American conservatism has taken many often contradictory, but more often overlapping forms over recent decades.
    • Apr 12, 2018
  • More »

Most Recent Comments

  • Re: Talking baseball

    • I loved Bill Elder "calling" the Travs games on the road. He did it by…

    • on May 22, 2018
  • Re: Talking baseball

    • 1090 was Little Rock's own Mighty 1090 KAAY, the greatest radio station ever. But i…

    • on May 22, 2018
  • Re: Ways to serve

    • A sharper distinction between example of Outstanding Character and No Character could not have been…

    • on May 21, 2018
 

© 2018 Arkansas Times | 201 East Markham, Suite 200, Little Rock, AR 72201
Powered by Foundation